Skip to content
Mandy - Blog Header

EPISODE #119

MANDY KELLOGG RYE

Pressure Is A Privilege: How Mandy Kellogg Rye Built Waiting on Martha

Listen on Spotify
Listen on Youtube
Listen on Apple Podcasts
Listen on Amazon Music

"Failure has never dissuaded me from doing something. I literally don't care about it."

 

Mandy Kellogg Rye, founder of Waiting on Martha, isn’t one to shy away from opportunity out of fear of failure. Her tenacity and courage are the threads that run through everything she's built. On this episode of The Market Makers, she sits down with Jon Pertchik discussing her foundational small-town childhood to the momentous day when Martha Stewart called and changed everything.

 

Mandy grew up watching her dad hold two jobs — realtor by day, wastewater treatment plant worker by night. Occasionally, he’d bring Mandy along for the ride, and she witnessed his drive at an early age. Her parents never told her no was a final answer. They never framed mistakes as something to avoid. "Making mistakes was not a bad thing," she says, "and I still feel that way." At 75, her parents still showed up to help Mandy lay tile in her store's new entranceway for three straight days. That work ethic isn't something she learned. It's something she absorbed.

 

Her brand, Waiting on Martha, started with no intention at all. Mandy was a top-performing sales rep in healthcare consulting when she noticed a creative spark inside her that had never found an outlet. Shortly afterward, Etsy launched. Blogs started appearing everywhere. And one night, wine in hand, she decided to start a blog. She designed her own pink-and-orange logo and gave it a name based on the movie she was half-watching. She hit publish with, as she puts it, "zero thought of failure, zero thought about the name, zero thought about anything." Three months later, Martha Stewart called.

 

What followed was a roller coaster of success, including Pottery Barn partnerships, magazine shoots and eventually her brick-and-mortar store. This outcome wasn’t built on luck – it was a result of being genuine and refusing to perform a version of herself that didn't exist.

 

Mandy kept her corporate job for four more years, but continued growing her brand the same way she started: championing what she believed in. "When I get on social media and tell the people that follow me I love this product," she says, "they don't question it. They know I love that product." That trust took years to build. It's also why her team has a rule: no unnecessary apologies. "Women apologize way too much," Mandy says. "We're not doing that."

 

But Mandy is honest in a way that's rare. She doesn't skip over the hardships. Last year, she called her landlord ready to break a ten-year lease. She thought she was done, but the people who knew her best told her to take a week before making any decisions. She did, and she stayed. "For the first time in a long time," she says, "I'm really excited and feel very invigorated by the business and retail as a whole again."

 

New categories are on the horizon. A rebrand is underway. And Mandy is reviving something she knows the retail community needs: a space to connect, commiserate, and support each other. Because as she puts it, pressure is a privilege.

Kellog Rye - Grid

Want more conversations like this?

More amazing guests are on deck. Subscribe
to stay in the loop.